Peter Costello

Media Transcripts

Telstra, tax, leadership, Indonesia - Doorstop Interview, Malvern, Victoria

Doorstop Interview
Northbrook
Malvern, Victoria

Friday, 2 September 2005
12.30 pm

SUBJECTS: Telstra, tax, leadership, Indonesia

JOURNALIST:

Mr Costello, your response to Telstra executives talking down the share price?

TREASURER:

Look, the directors of Telstra have an obligation to all of their shareholders and that obligation of course is to so run the company as to make profits and to give them a good return on their investment. And I think the directors will want to maximise the price for their shareholders who include a lot of private mums and dads but also the Government. That is their obligation as directors.

JOURNALIST:

So have their actions been consistent with their duties as directors?

TREASURER:

Well, obviously the directors have to act in the interests of their shareholders, but what is the interest of the shareholders? The interest of the shareholders is a price which is rising and they have got to take their decisions accordingly to preserve value for their shareholders.

JOURNALIST:

Is this is the right leadership team to be running Telstra at the moment?

TREASURER:

Look, it is a very difficult job being a director of Telstra because this is a company which is half owned by the Government, half owned by private shareholders, they are in a very difficult conflict situation on occasion and it is really the reason why the shareholding has to be worked out. It has to be resolved one way or the other otherwise you are going to have competing demands placed on this company and its directors which will make life very difficult.

JOURNALIST:

Would you personally like the shareholders to take a lower public profile?

TREASURER:

Do you mean the directors?

JOURNALIST:

The directors, sorry.

TREASURER:

Look, the Directors’ obligation is to the shareholders. They have got to do what is in the interests of the shareholders. The Government’s obligation is to ensure there is a competitive framework. The Government’s obligation is to ensure that the ownership is resolved. The Government’s obligation is to determine what happens to the proceeds. Those are matters for the Government. The matters for the directors of course are to so run the company as to preserve value and increase value for shareholders. And I think there are different players here with different focuses and we have got to remember whose focus is what.

JOURNALIST:

Do you have some sympathy with the directors who are saying that there is too much regulation proposed for a privatised Telstra?

TREASURER:

No, I don’t believe that there is too much regulation. There is a regulatory system which is designed to promote competition and Telstra has to work within that. That is not an over-regulatory system, it is a system which is there to enable competitors to come into the market and keep prices low for consumers. I wouldn’t want to see a less competitive regime than we currently have in relation to Telstra.

JOURNALIST:

Do you think the new group that are leading Telstra have misjudged the unique nature of telecommunications here in Australia?

TREASURER:

Look, it is a very difficult arrangement at the moment. Telstra is not a normal company. It is a company that has half private ownership and 51 per cent Government ownership. What that means is there are competing demands. There are political demands from the majority shareholder, there are investment demands from the mums and dads and this really illustrates why the whole ownership has got to be resolved. You have got to resolve it one way or another, it has got to either be a public company or a private company and until you resolve that you are going to have these difficulties.

JOURNALIST:

What do you think of their approach to government relations?

TREASURER:

Well, that is a matter for them.

JOURNALIST:

If the share price goes down below $2, would you consider nationalising it?

TREASURER:

I don’t think any government would get into the business of renationalising Telstra. There is nowhere in the world where telecommunications is moving in the direction of nationalisation. There are places in the world where it is moving in favour of privatisation but there is nowhere in the world where it is moving in favour of nationalisation.

JOURNALIST:

What about the fact Phil Burgess said he wouldn’t recommend his mother buy shares?

TREASURER:

Well, I don’t know that we were looking for his mother to be a major shareholder…

JOURNALIST:

But we are talking about mums and dads…

TREASURER:

…that is a matter for Phil Burgess’ mother.

JOURNALIST:

What about your mother….

TREASURER:

I don’t give investment advice to my mother either.

JOURNALIST:

Just on tax Mr Costello, you were saying earlier in the week that Mr Turnbull should come out with some specific proposals. He has come out with two specific options that he is prepared to put his name to today. What do you think of those two proposals?

TREASURER:

Look, people are prepared to put forward options, that is all part of the political debate. The Government’s responsibility however is to balance the Budget, keep interest rates low, fund health and aged care and to hold all of that in balance with a good competitive tax system. And the Government policy which we brought down at the last Budget does all of those things whilst cutting taxes by $22 billion. You know, we have got an obligation to the whole of Australia, to all of the taxpayers, we can’t just single out one class of taxpayer. We have got an obligation to all taxpayers to make sure that the tax system is as competitive as possible and we can hold that together with balanced Budgets, repaying debt, keeping interest rates low, funding health, funding aged care and making sure Australia’s economy keeps growing.

JOURNALIST:

He says his proposal does look after all taxpayers in a sense that it raises the tax free threshold as well as dropping the top marginal rate.

TREASURER:

Well as I say, the Government has got a responsibility in all areas of economic policy – not just tax, but expenditure, interest rates and of course balancing the Budget. And of course in an ideal world we wouldn’t have those constraints but unfortunately we take the world as we find it. And the important thing at the moment is keeping the Budget in surplus because that is a big part of our strategy to keep interest rates down. I have said over and over and over again, this Government is not going to do anything that will put pressure on interest rates for homebuyers.

JOURNALIST:

So you reject those two proposals?

TREASURER:

No I said the Government welcomes people putting forward any proposals that they like. But the Government has to take a decision in the interests of all taxpayers and it has to be taken not just in respect of tax but in respect of expenditures, in respect of budget outcomes, in respect of monetary policy. We have got to make sure that it is consistent with good macroeconomic management.

JOURNALIST:

Mr Costello, your former colleague John Hewson said on radio today that the Prime Minister is unlikely to be retiring any time soon. Now what do you make of those comments, do you agree with him?

TREASURER:

Well you would have to refer those to Dr Hewson.

JOURNALIST:

Mr Costello, on high petrol prices, today we are seeing Victorian commuters are going more to public transport and getting off the roads because of high petrol prices. Do you think that that is a trend that we might see across Australia?

TREASURER:

Look, I don’t like petrol prices being as high as they are. It is bad for consumers and it is bad for the economy. But if higher prices are going to be with us for some time - and they may well be - then I think consumers are increasingly going to be drawn to cars that have lower petrol consumption. The days of the four wheel drive in suburban streets might be coming to an end. People may well be looking at smaller cars because they give better consumption and that wouldn’t be an altogether bad thing.

JOURNALIST:

How do you think Hurricane Katrina will effect the Australian economy?

TREASURER:

Well the immediate effec… Let me say first of all, this hurricane has done enormous damage, there had been loss of life and I think all of us feel for those that are suffering and our good wishes are with the people of New Orleans and the Americans south in this time of trial. What has the effect been immediately? Well it has obviously pushed up oil prices because it has reduced production out of the Gulf of Mexico. What is the consequence of that? Petrol prices are higher. What is the consequence of that? That will dent other areas of consumption in the Australian economy, so it is not a good result. Higher petrol prices are in no one’s interest but we hope that once those rigs get back into production, coupled with increased production elsewhere in the world, the oil price will come back and petrol prices will come down but it is going to be a matter of time.

JOURNALIST:

Indonesia is facing some fairly tough economic decisions ahead. Will you be giving any advice to the Indonesian President when you are there about how to manage that?

TREASURER:

Oh no, we don’t go to give advice. I will be going to meet with senior members of the Indonesian Government and particularly to talk about Australia’s role in reconstruction in Aceh. We have made a pledge of $1 billion. It is the largest pledge that has ever been made on behalf of Australia. We are now actively working for the reconstruction in Aceh and I want to go, I want to see what progress has been made, to see that the money is getting through and getting to the people who need it. And because I am one of the two Ministers responsible for that billion dollar project, I think it is important that we get up there and make sure the people who need it are helped, the Australian taxpayers are assured that their money is getting through, and that large aid project is alleviating suffering for people who suffered terribly in a tsunami.

2 Sep 2005

View more media transcripts …

Latest News

Paris Diary

Peter Costello Paris Diary

Read more …

PPI - Rising Role of Sovereign Wealth Funds

Peter Costello Rising Role of Sovereign Funds Speech

Read more …

The Hole Truth

Peter Costello in the Daily Telegraph

Read more …

Videos

Video Screenshot

Watch videos …